Unlike statements of fact, values can be disputed. We dispute value claims in two ways

Unlike statements of fact, values can be disputed. We dispute value claims in two ways

Unlike statements of fact, values can be disputed. We dispute value claims in two ways:

1) We can question whether someone truly holds or practices the value of which they speak. For instance, if someone claims you as a friend, but then always cancels plans at the last minute, you might question whether the person really values friendship.

2) We can dispute the meaning or definition of a value term. For example, maybe a friend of yours has elected not to pursue a college degree because they don’t want to commit to a specific career path early in life. Perhaps the friend tells you, “I like my freedom.” You might argue with your friend that a lack of education narrows job options and limits opportunities. Freedom, you might tell them, means having options and opportunities.

The value terms that we use signal our beliefs about life, the world, other people, and ourselves. Even more telling is how we use those terms and how we define them. This assignment asks you to reflect on a value term that speaks to you. It is the first step toward the Meaning Of….essay. The assignment has four parts explained below.